08-24-2015, 02:46 PM
(08-24-2015, 02:34 PM)SharpTeeth Wrote:Except that he isn't trying to economize or sell anything, nor is it THAT serious that everything requires a checkout with real-world physics and laws, because it's a fictional creation.(08-24-2015, 02:25 PM)USegolia Wrote: Can you not see how circular your argument is here? In the same statement you quoted, ryuu already acknowledges that he gave minimal considersation to the scientifics of the lore he added, only having added it at all to satisfy people demanding him for an explanation.Let me repeat myself again: The excessive detail isn't needed, and him adding it at the behest of others is a rather flimsy excuse. My motive is listed up on the older post up. I think you believe I am viciously attacking it for no reason, and in a knee jerk response, neglected to carefully read what my points are.
I really don't understand what your goal is here? Are you trying to show that the avali as described by their lore are not viable as an actual species? If that's the case, the creator (ryuu) has openly accepted and acknowledged this, citing that they were never intended to be and making several statements to that effect.
Is there some other motive? If so, please enlighten us. It seems to me that you want some particular outcome out of this, given the inordinate amount of time and effort you are putting into making your point - I mean you wrote more or less an entire essay on the topic.
You are free to criticize, same as anybody, but there's no rule against what Ryuu can or cannot do with his own creations or how he decides to explain them.
So do at least try to be civil. If Ryuu doesn't accept your suggestions or criticisms, then back off. He's under no obligation to fulfill any of it, and given your past attitude I don't expect him to.